Refine Search
Sort by
$599,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 2,690 SqFt. 0.41000000000000003 Acres 98996610 MLS
Lots of history behind this custom-built home w/indoor swimming pool! Large corner lot in a wonderful location near the highly respected College of Idaho & the fun filled Indian Creek development in downtown Caldwell. This 5 bedroom 3 bath home is surrounded by stately older homes & is in the Steunenberg historical District! The mature landscaping is attractive & provides a pleasing ambience. The kitchen was remodeled when current owners purchases. The indoor pool provides hours of entertaining. The living room is gorgeous w/coved ceilings, fireplace & lots of windows. This custom built three level 1939 home has character. All data deemed reliable but not guaranteed, buyer to verify all information.

1824 Everett St, Caldwell

$?
4 Beds 2 Baths 2,610 SqFt. 0.21 Acres 98991270 MLS
Rare opportunity to own a one-of-a-kind Klinker brick residence in the highly coveted Steunenberg Historic District. Adding to its rich heritage, this home was originally built by the prominent Evans family, longtime Caldwell residents known for owning a successful fishing lure manufacturing. Their legacy lives on throughout the home's enduring craftsmanship, distinctive architecture, & timeless character. Perfectly positioned on a beautifully manicured corner lot with mature trees & lush landscaping, this iconic property blends timeless architectural character with exceptional versatility. Inside, you'll find inviting living spaces including a family room, formal dining, two main-level bedrooms & an updated bathroom featuring granite countertops & dual vanities. Upstairs, a generous bonus room or additional bedroom provides flexible living options, while the lower level offers a utility area, tons of storage, bedroom and bathroom. Adding to the property's appeal is a detached 2-car garage & ADU cottage (Kitchen, living, 1 bed & bath), creating an incredible opportunity for rental income, guest accommodations or multi-generational living. Major updates include new HVAC & duct work ('18), electrical & garage door ('25), plumbing ('26), ADU roof, & exterior doors. Located less than one mile from The College of Idaho and vibrant Indian Creek Plaza.

1424 Dearborn St, Caldwell

$474,950
4 Beds 2 Baths 2,411 SqFt. 0.2 Acres 98991009 MLS
BACK ON MARKET! Inviting front porch welcomes into this Classic Turn of the Century home. Tasteful decor -Updates include: electrical -plumbing- HVAC -roof, many interior & exterior updates. Detached garage/shop totally renovated with auto opener -large shop area with 220. Home features a full bath & bedroom on the main level- 3 bedrooms & bath upstairs. Hardwood floors on the main level with large dining room - built ins - the open living area featuring a gas insert fireplace & additional sitting area. The kitchen features granite counters, lots of newer cabinetry. Recessed lighting & white appliances compliment the expansive counters with newer double oven, stove, microwave & dishwasher. A pop out nook with large windows offers plenty of natural light for morning breakfast. The covered back entrance includes large windows - area for washer & dryer. The basement is unfinished with plentiful space for workshop or addl storage. 2 sets of stairs- the back stairs open to a windowed upper porch/craft area with access to the bedrooms on either side. The Main staircase is adjacent to the living room and has been restored to it's original beauty with carpet runner & gorgeous wood railing. Upstairs are 3 large bedrooms each with nice closets & extra storage space. The Main bedroom accesses a lovely enclosed porch for a bonus sitting or walk in closet. Upgrades & amenities in docs!

1904 Blaine St, Caldwell

$?
4 Beds 2 Baths 1,584 SqFt. 0.1 Acres 98989433 MLS
Location, flexibility, and charm come together in this Caldwell gem. Situated approximately half a mile from the beautiful College of Idaho campus and less than a mile from the restaurants, events, and entertainment of Indian Creek Plaza, this home offers an unbeatable location in the heart of one of Caldwell's most vibrant neighborhoods. Inside, you'll find a unique layout that provides exceptional flexibility for a variety of living situations. Whether you're looking for a traditional residence, multi generational living, or a house hacking opportunity, this property delivers with two separate living spaces. The main level features two bedrooms, beautiful hardwood floors, and inviting living areas filled with character and warmth. Downstairs, the finished basement offers a full bathroom, egress window, and durable concrete floors, creating additional living space with endless possibilities. Step outside and enjoy a new concrete patio slab and pergola, perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or enjoying Idaho's beautiful summer evenings. With its prime location, versatile floor plan, and thoughtful updates, this is a rare opportunity to own a home that offers both lifestyle and investment potential.

515 S 16th Ave, Caldwell

$?
1 Beds 1 Baths 1,332 SqFt. 0.14 Acres 98981458 MLS
Prime Caldwell location near the College of Idaho and Indian Creek Plaza. The main level features a bedroom, bath, living room, kitchen, formal dining, and breakfast nook. Enjoy abundant natural light in the sunroom and a cozy wood stove for winter months. The finished basement includes two rooms with closets and windows, offering potential for egress conversion to create two additional bedrooms, plus a large bonus/family room. Updates include a new roof, fresh interior and exterior paint, and hardwood floors. Outside, enjoy the backyard which features mature trees and a detached garage/shop. Ideally located in the heart of town, this home offers great potential for owner-occupants or as a rental investment. Some photos have been virtually staged. NOTE: Sellers need to close on or before June 22nd, or they will retain the property as a rental. Some pictures are AI staged.

1721 Blaine St, Caldwell

$?
2 Beds 1 Baths 881 SqFt. 0.2 Acres 98976998 MLS
Walking distance to College of Idaho! Charming historic cottage nestled in the Caldwell Historic District, full of character and thoughtful modern updates. This classic home has the perfect & safe college location. This inviting home features 2 bedrooms and 1 beautifully remodeled bathroom, blending timeless charm with comfortable living. Welcoming front porch invites you inside where the living room has original hardwood floors, adding warmth and authenticity to the space. The kitchen is both stylish and functional, featuring gorgeous Acacia wood butcher block countertops, a ceramic farmhouse sink, new luxury vinyl tile flooring, some new plumbing & electrical. Just off the kitchen, a charming alcove creates the perfect coffee bar or beverage station, adding both convenience & character. The bright sunroom offers wonderful natural light & doubles as a spacious walk-in closet for the primary bedroom, creating a unique & practical addition. Recent updates throughout include new interior paint (2025), updated lighting fixtures, a new barn door, & new flooring in the second bedroom. The bathroom remodel is fresh & charming. Major improvements bring peace of mind with a roof & water heater approximately five years old along with a new cellar door. Outside, the oversized lot offers endless possibilities, with alley access parking, a storage shed, & ample space to build a shop or ADU.

1615 Fillmore St, Caldwell

$?
6 Beds 3 Baths 2,743 SqFt. 0.22 Acres 98972122 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully renovated corner-lot gem located in the heart of Caldwell’s sought-after Steunenberg Historical District. This expansive home has been completely updated inside and out, featuring brand-new flooring, fresh interior and exterior paint, updated hardware, modern appliances, stylish fixtures, and much more. Offering incredible flexibility, this property can be used as a single large residence or as a duplex with two distinct living spaces. The lower level has its own private entrances, full kitchen, three bedrooms, and a full bath—complete with egress windows in each bedroom. The upper level boasts a spacious living area, a large master suite with a private bath, two additional bedrooms, and a separate guest bathroom. Ideal for multi-generational living or investment-minded buyers, this home includes two laundry areas downstairs and separate washer/dryer hookups upstairs. With endless potential and a prime location, this property is an exceptional opportunity you won’t want to miss!

1704 Blaine, Caldwell

$?
5 Beds 3 Baths 2,567 SqFt. 1.73 Acres 98967248 MLS
An exceptional 1900s home that is perfectly positioned on a rare 1.73-acre lot that is near the Indian Creek Plaza of downtown Caldwell. The property blends a private country feel with the luxury of modern conveniences. The minute you open the door into this 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom gem you find that it honors its historic soul through expansive living spaces with original hardwood floors, a separate formal dining area and breakfast nook all while offering the contemporary luxury of a modernized kitchen. The backyard serves as a true private sanctuary, anchored by an inground swimming pool, a dedicated pool house, and an extensive paver patio where the soothing sounds of a custom water feature create an unmatched atmosphere for grand-scale entertaining. Offering a little over an acre in the back fenced yard/pasture, you have ample room for your horses or livestock with the ability to utilize flood irrigation. Beyond your gates, you are just one mile from the vibrant energy of downtown Caldwell’s Indian Creek Plaza, home to premier dining, boutique shopping, and iconic year-round festivities like the Winter Wonderland Festival. Whether you are exploring Idaho’s famed Sunnyslope wineries less than 20 minutes away or utilizing the swift access to I-84 for an easy commute, this property offers a lifestyle of timeless elegance and unparalleled location.

1917 Arthur St, Caldwell

$?
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,674 SqFt. 0.17 Acres 98965693 MLS
Well-maintained single-family home that’s move-in ready and perfect for first-time home buyers or investment property. Inside, you’ll find two bedrooms, one full bathroom, a kitchen, and a laundry room upstairs. Downstairs offers an entirely separate living area, kitchen, bathroom, bedroom, and laundry hook-ups. This property offers the right mix of personal space and shared areas for a family or college students. This home provides the flexibility to make it your own and can be easily transformed to suit your needs. The generous yard provides plenty of space for gardening, entertaining, or simply enjoying the outdoors. Start your mornings with a cup of coffee inside the enclosed porch, or invite friends and family over for summer barbecues and gatherings. Extra parking gives you added convenience for guests, trailers, or recreational equipment. Located in Caldwell's Historical District, close to everything: College of Idaho, Shopping, parks, and freeway access. Everything you need is just a short drive away, helping you settle into your new routine and explore the charm of your community. Don’t miss this fantastic opportunity!

1812 Cleveland Blvd, Caldwell

$?
6 Beds 2 Baths 2,092 SqFt. 0.14 Acres 98965091 MLS
Charming 1931 home in Caldwell’s Steunenberg Historic District, perfectly located across from the College of Idaho and just minutes from Indian Creek Plaza. This beautifully maintained 6-bedroom, 2-bath residence blends vintage character with thoughtful updates. Enjoy original hardwood floors, built-ins, and classic wood doors throughout. The main level features two bedrooms and a full bath, while the lower level offers four additional bedrooms, laundry, and storage space. Upstairs includes a bonus room between two cozy bedrooms—ideal for an office or study. Recent updates include a new roof (2020) and fresh exterior paint (June 2025). Situated on a corner lot with mature trees, a carport, and a private driveway. This home has been a fully occupied rental for the past five years, making it a great opportunity for investors or owner-occupants alike. Walk to downtown shops, restaurants, and parks with easy freeway access nearby & across the street from the College of Idaho campus!

1922 Everett St, Caldwell

$?
3 Beds 2 Baths 2,746 SqFt. 0.21 Acres 98963382 MLS
Step into timeless elegance at 1805 Everett Street, a 1931 Tudor Revival cottage in Caldwell’s prestigious Steunenberg Historic District. Encompassing 2,770 sq ft, the main home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, and beautifully preserved architectural details, from coved ceilings and arched doorways to original leaded glass doorknobs and rare eucalyptus wood trim. The living room’s centerpiece is a striking Batchelder-Wilson tiled fireplace—an extraordinary “Mayan Derivative” design crafted in Pasadena. A second fireplace enhances the lower-level family room, while a hidden dumbwaiter adds historic charm and carry’s logs from one fireplace to the other. The thoughtfully remodeled kitchen showcases Delft polychrome tiles from the 1920s, custom bead board cabinetry, and Marmoleum tile flooring, blending heritage with modern utility. Completing the property is a detached 312 sq ft ADU with kitchenette and bath, perfect for guests, work, or private retreat. This is a rare opportunity to own a landmark of historic and architectural distinction.

1805 Everett Street, Caldwell

$?
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,680 SqFt. 0.14 Acres 98961880 MLS
This 1937 historic home blends timeless charm with incredible potential. Located near West Valley Medical, College of Western Idaho, Indian Creek Plaza, schools, and restaurants, it’s a place you’ll instantly love. Great potential to turn this home into a duplex. Upstairs features 2 bedrooms, bathroom, living room, dining, and kitchen. The lower level has a bedroom, bonus room (office/den), bathroom, second kitchen, living room, and laundry and can easily have a private entry. The spacious backyard with mature trees offers room for a larger garage, RV parking and features a shed and a gate to the alley. With a prime location and great rental potential, this home is perfect for multi-generational living or as an investment property. Bring your tools, your vision, and your HGTV dreams. The opportunity to transform this house into a stunning showcase is waiting. Property is sold "as is." Don't miss this chance to invest in a prime piece of Caldwell real estate!

1422 Everett Street, Caldwell

$?
4 Beds 3 Baths 3,717 SqFt. 0.21 Acres 98954631 MLS
Step into a piece of Caldwell’s history with this remarkable 1912 home, originally built by Julia Finney, a professor at the College of Idaho. Steeped in legacy, the residence later became the official home of the College President from 1940 through the 1960s. Located in the coveted Caldwell Historic District, this timeless property seamlessly blends the charm of its storied past with thoughtful updates for modern living. From the moment you enter, the grand entry welcomes you with elegance and character. Gorgeous hardwood floors, tall ceilings, and diamond leaded glass windows reflect the craftsmanship of a bygone era, while modern enhancements provide comfort and convenience. A graceful butler staircase adds both architectural interest and functional charm, connecting the home's spaces with a nod to tradition. This is more than just a home—it’s a rare opportunity to own a piece of local history, beautifully preserved.

1804 Everett St, Caldwell

$?
2 Beds 2 Baths 1,532 SqFt. 0.1 Acres 98949855 MLS
This two bed, two bath home showcases classic and mid-century charm with inviting curb appeal. Located in historic Steunenberg district, this home is centrally located to all amenities Caldwell has to offer, including medical, shopping, bus transportation, two blocks from the College of Idaho. Also located just over a mile from Indian Creek Plaza. where residents can easily enjoy the vibrant downtown atmosphere including seasonal events, concerts and local markets. Enjoy your morning/evening drink on this inviting porch with gorgeous landscaping. New water heater, air conditioning and roof installed in the last five years. Beautiful wood flooring in the living and dining room areas. Covered carport and shed also on property.

414 S 18th Ave, Caldwell

$?
4 Beds 2 Baths 2,836 SqFt. 0.14 Acres 98916218 MLS
Craftsman charm meets fresh updates in Caldwell's Steunenberg Historic District. New exterior paint! Inside you will find gorgeous windows, ample hardwood and beautiful woodwork, trim and built-ins. The room sizes are good + the floor plan has a nice flow. Two spacious bedrooms are on the main floor and there are two bedrooms down + bonus areas for flexible living. The living rm is a show-stopper that features a gas fireplace surrounded by built-ins original to the home and storybook windows. The adjoining formal dining room is roomy with easy connectivity to the kitchen. The loft space w/charming nooks is perfect for a multi-use area- exercise or office or media room? Lots of options w/this home. The basement with updated bath presents it's own flexible living opportunities. Exterior features include front and back porches, a detached garage + carport parking and irrigation. Close to College of Idaho, restaurants and shopping plus easy access to the freeway. This is a must-see home!

1615 Cleveland Blvd, Caldwell

$?
3 Beds 3 Baths 2,315 SqFt. 0.21 Acres 98904962 MLS
Welcome to this Southern-style cottage, a timeless gem built in 1920 that effortlessly blends original charm with contemporary comforts. Step into a bygone era where character abounds in every corner, from the quaint enclosed sun porch to the detailed craftsmanship throughout. This well-maintained home boasts all the classic elements of its era, including hardwood floors, vintage fixtures, and elegant millwork, preserving its historic allure all while modern updates are seamlessly integrated. The perfect balance of old-world charm and convenience. Did I mention the large backyard with garden, fruit trees, and chicken coop? Income potential -- rent out the basement apartment. Located within 3 blocks of C of I and within walking distance to restaurants or drive 4 minutes to Indian Creek Plaza. 5 minutes to the freeway. Call today to schedule your private tour!

1614 Dearborn St, Caldwell

$?
2 Beds 1 Baths 558 SqFt. 0.09 Acres 98902508 MLS
NO HOA! So much potential! First time home buyers and investors this has your name on it! All the major updates done! Remodeled in 2018, features new countertops, windows, water heater, disposal, roof, fixtures, and appliances, making it perfect for first-time buyers or as an investment for rental or Airbnb. Featuring electric wall heaters in each room for individual comfort. Corner lot with large backyard to create your own backyard oasis with plenty of room for RV parking and garden space! Situated near The College of Idaho, Caldwell Night Rodeo, Indian Creek Plaza, Luxe Movie Theatre, and a variety of shops and restaurants, it's at the heart of Caldwell's vibrant transformation. With Indian Creek Plaza revitalizing the area and bringing in visitors, this property is not just a home but a gateway to endless possibilities in a community full of life and growth! Seize this charming opportunity before it's gone!

202 S 18th Ave., Caldwell


Information courtesy of Intermountain Multiple Listing Service. Information provided by IMLS is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non‐commercial use, it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. IMLS does not assume any liability for missing or inaccurate data. All listings provided by IMLS are marked with the official IMLS IDX icon.